Book Review: An Islamic Perspective on Governance Zafar Iqbal

An Islamic Perspective on Governance

Book Review: An Islamic Perspective on Governance Zafar Iqbal

Before Buying, Better to Read the Book Review: An Islamic Perspective on Governance Zafar Iqbal by Legaproblema.com - Have you ever wondered how governance principles differ when viewed through the lens of Islamic political theory? In our review of book An Islamic Perspective on Governance Zafar Iqbal, we delve into the intricate ways Islamic views on state management and governance in Islam contrast and complement Western governance models. This book challenges us to rethink governance principles by integrating classical Islamic teachings with contemporary political and economic realities.¹

Iqbal and Lewis bring forward a unique synthesis of Islamic leadership principles, exploring justice, accountability, and corruption from an Islamic perspective. They argue that understanding governance in Islam requires a deep grasp of its legal traditions and philosophy, which shape the Islamic political theory underpinning the book analysis.⁵ This perspective is not merely theoretical but incorporates practical insights from modern governance challenges faced by Muslim-majority states.

In this review, we explore how the book addresses public, economic, and corporate governance, highlighting the Islamic approach to taxation, budget deficits, and public accountability. The authors’ integration of public choice theory with Islamic governance principles offers a fresh, nuanced understanding of governance in Islam that is both normative and positive.²

Book Details

Author

Zafar Iqbal and Mervyn K. Lewis

Original Language

English

Translation

-

Publisher

Edward Elgar Publishing Limited

ISBN

9781847201386

Length

368 pages

Genre

Academic, Islamic Political Theory, Governance Studies

Structure and Contents

How is the book structured to unpack the complex topic of governance in Islam? The book is organized into ten chapters plus a preface, each focusing on critical facets of governance from an Islamic standpoint. Below are key elements covered:¹

• Theories of justice in Islamic governance
• Taxation and public finance under Islamic law
• Budget deficits and their management
• Islamic financing modes and economic governance
• Public and private accountability mechanisms
• Corruption and its prevention in Islamic governance
• Comparisons between Islamic and Western governance models
• Integration of classical Islamic teachings with contemporary governance challenges
• Application of public choice theory to Islamic governance
• Policy implications for Muslim-majority states

Strong Points of the Book

What makes book An Islamic Perspective on Governance Zafar Iqbal stand out in the field of Islamic political theory and governance principles? Here are its strong points:⁶

• Innovative integration: Combines classical Islamic jurisprudence with modern governance theories, offering a fresh perspective.
• Comprehensive coverage: Addresses public, economic, and corporate governance comprehensively from an Islamic viewpoint.
• Normative and positive approach: Balances ideal Islamic governance principles with practical realities and self-interested behavior.
• Public choice dimension: Acknowledges human behavior complexities in governance, enhancing the realism of its analysis.
• Bridges East and West: Offers comparative insights that enrich understanding of governance in Islam vis-à-vis Western models.
• Relevance: Provides valuable insights for policymakers, scholars, and students interested in Islamic economics and governance.

Impact and Legacy

How has this book influenced discussions on governance in Islam and Islamic leadership principles? Since its publication, book An Islamic Perspective on Governance Zafar Iqbal has become a reference point in academic and policy circles examining governance in Islam. It has:⁸

• Stimulated further research into underexplored areas of Islamic governance, such as public finance and accountability.
• Encouraged dialogue between Islamic scholars and Western political economists, fostering interdisciplinary approaches.
• Contributed to the development of governance frameworks in Muslim-majority countries seeking to align governance with Islamic values.
• Enhanced understanding of how Islamic views on state management can inform contemporary governance reforms.

Zafar Iqbal

Criticism of the Book

Does the book face any critiques regarding its approach to governance in Islam? While widely praised, some critiques include:⁸

• Complexity: The dense academic style may be challenging for general readers or practitioners unfamiliar with Islamic jurisprudence or economic theory.
• Scope limitations: Some argue it could engage more deeply with diverse Islamic schools of thought beyond the dominant Sunni perspectives.
• Practical application: Critics note that while theoretically rich, the book could offer more concrete case studies illustrating governance principles in action.
• Comparative balance: The contrast with Western governance, though insightful, might benefit from broader global governance perspectives.

Comparison with Other Similar Books

How does this book compare with other works on Islamic political theory and governance principles? A brief comparison:⁷

Feature	An Islamic Perspective on Governance	Islamic Political Thought by Gerhard Bowering	Governance in the Muslim World by Khaled Abou El Fadl
Focus	Governance principles integrating economics, law, and accountability	Historical and philosophical development of Islamic political theory	Contemporary governance challenges and reform in Muslim countries
Approach	Normative and positive, blending classical and modern insights	Primarily historical and textual analysis	Policy-oriented with emphasis on human rights and democracy
Usefulness for Practitioners	High, especially for scholars and policymakers	More academic, suited for students	Practical policy recommendations
Comparative Analysis	Explicit comparison with Western governance models	Limited comparative focus	Focus on Muslim-majority states with some global context

Islamic Political Theory

What does Islamic political theory teach us about governance in Islam, and how does book An Islamic Perspective on Governance Zafar Iqbal contribute to this field? Islamic political theory is grounded in the Quran, Sunnah, and centuries of jurisprudence, emphasizing justice, consultation (shura), and accountability. This book enriches the discourse by:¹

• Providing a systematic framework that integrates classical Islamic principles with modern governance challenges.
• Highlighting the role of justice and ethical leadership as central to Islamic governance principles.
• Exploring how economic policies like taxation and public finance align with Islamic teachings.

Governance Principles

Why are governance principles in Islam distinct, and what lessons does the book offer? Governance principles in Islam prioritize:⁵

• Accountability to God and the community
• Transparency and prevention of corruption
• Equity in justice and economic distribution
• Consultation and participatory decision-making

The book articulates these principles clearly, showing their practical implications for state management and policy formulation.

Islamic Leadership Principles

What defines Islamic leadership principles, and how does the book address them? Islamic leadership is characterized by:⁶

• Adherence to moral and ethical standards
• Service to the community rather than personal gain
• Accountability and humility
• Emphasis on justice and welfare

The authors discuss these principles in the context of governance, emphasizing leaders’ responsibilities and the mechanisms to ensure good governance in Islam.

Islamic Views on State Management

How does Islam view state management, and what insights does the book provide? Islamic views on state management stress:¹

• Balancing authority with justice and mercy
• Implementing laws based on Shariah while accommodating public welfare
• Ensuring economic justice through fair taxation and resource distribution
• Maintaining social order with ethical governance

The book explores these themes deeply, offering a blueprint for state management rooted in Islamic teachings yet adaptable to modern contexts.

Governance in Islam

What does governance in Islam encompass, and how does this book illuminate its principles? Governance in Islam is a holistic concept involving:⁵

• Political authority exercised within ethical and legal boundaries
• Economic management aligned with Islamic finance principles
• Social justice and protection of rights
• Mechanisms to prevent corruption and ensure accountability

This book comprehensive approach helps readers understand governance in Islam not only as a theoretical ideal but as a practical system with real-world applications.

Final Ruling

In sum, book An Islamic Perspective on Governance Zafar Iqbal is an essential read for anyone interested in Islamic political theory and governance principles. It bridges classical Islamic teachings with contemporary governance challenges, offering insightful analysis on Islamic leadership principles and Islamic views on state management. While academic in tone, its contributions to understanding governance in Islam are profound and enduring, making it a valuable resource for scholars, policymakers, and students alike.⁸

Do you also have questions? Or curious about where you can download the book, read the book online, or buy the book online? Or want to add something more to the review above and give responses? You can write a comment below.