Before Buying, Better to Read Book Review: Proof of Celebrating Mawlid-un Nabi from Quran and Sahih Hadith Hammad Raza by Legaproblema.com - It wrong to say "Happy Birthday, Nabi"? Are we violating religious norms, or simply expressing our love for the Prophet in a modern idiom? These questions lie at the core of Proof of Celebrating Mawlid-un Nabi from Quran and Sahih Hadith Hammad Raza. In this richly documented study, we are guided through a scholarly yet accessible defence of celebrating the birth of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), supported directly by scriptural texts from both the Qur’an and authentic Hadith.

At a time when the global Muslim community is grappling with the polarization of traditional and reformist interpretations, this book arrives like a balm. It seeks not to incite, but to illuminate. The author, Hammad Raza, assembles a thorough and respectful argument, blending classical sources with contemporary clarity. The result is an accessible read for believers navigating debates about Eid Mawlid al Nabi and whether such festivities are an innovation (bid’ah) or a blessed remembrance.

In each paragraph, the book reiterates that the celebration of Mawlid-un Nabi is not only justified but is fundamentally rooted in reverence—citing verses like Surah Yunus (10:58): “Say, ‘In the bounty of Allah and in His mercy – in that let them rejoice; it is better than what they accumulate.’” Raza interprets this as divine encouragement for celebration in remembrance of the Prophet's birth, supported by authentic Hadith affirming the Prophet’s own acknowledgment of his birthday through fasting on Mondays.

-

ISBN

171 pages

Genre

Islamic Theology, Seerah (Prophetic Biography), Contemporary Fiqh

Structure and Contents

What’s inside this book besides citations?

The book’s structure is thoughtfully laid out to guide the reader from uncertainty to conviction. Here’s how it unfolds:

• Introduction to the Mawlid Debate

• Qur’anic References Interpreted in Light of Mawlid

• Sahih Hadith Evidence Supporting the Celebration

• Historical Precedents from the Tabi‘un and Early Scholars

• Legal Rulings from Renowned Madhahib (Schools of Thought)

• Common Misconceptions About Mawlid

• Cultural Practices and Modern-Day Validations

• Appendices: Annotated Bibliography of Sources

The author includes more than 200 references from primary Islamic sources and interpretations by scholars such as Imam Suyuti, Ibn Hajar al-Asqalani, and even modern voices like Dr. Tahir-ul-Qadri. Each section concludes with a short summary, making the book easy to navigate even for lay readers.

Strong Points of the Book

Why should this book matter when there are already many voices on the subject?

This work’s strength lies in its methodical validation. Unlike sensationalist polemics that dominate public discourse on this issue, Book Review: Proof of Celebrating Mawlid-un Nabi from Quran and Sahih Hadith Hammad Raza relies on calm, source-based arguments. Consider this:

• Raza includes eight authentic Hadiths in which the Prophet speaks of the significance of his birth.

• He quotes historical evidence of public celebrations during the Fatimid and Ayyubid periods—well before accusations of bid’ah began surfacing.

• The book avoids generalizations, instead focusing on interpretive tradition backed by exegesis.

“Religious love should not be policed; it should be purified,” he writes. This encapsulates his tone: not defiant, but deliberate.

Impact and Legacy

Will this book shift perspectives or simply affirm those already convinced?

We believe the book has already started making ripples. It is now included in select madrasah curricula across Pakistan and South Africa. On platforms like Goodreads and Islamic forums, readers praise the book for its clarity and tact.

More broadly, it has offered a constructive tool in mosques and Islamic study circles, helping people articulate their views without confrontation. As discussions about Eid Mawlid al Nabi gain mainstream attention, the book is poised to become a reference point.

In South Asia especially, where religious discourse can quickly turn polarizing, this book is becoming a bridge between generations and ideologies.

Hammad Raza

Criticism of the Book

Is there any room for dissent or improvement?

Critics, particularly from Salafi or Wahhabi circles, argue that the book takes liberties in interpreting certain Hadith. They claim that while the Hadith of fasting on Mondays is authentic, linking it directly to the celebration of mawlid is a stretch.

Some also note that Raza may be preaching to the choir. The book does little to engage readers who already view Mawlid with suspicion. There are also calls for more engagement with modern reformist thinkers, which is currently missing.

Nonetheless, the scholarship remains solid, and even critics acknowledge the depth of sourcing.

Comparison with Other Similar Books

How does it compare with other works defending mawlid?

Books like “Milad-un Nabi: Evidence from Quran and Sunnah” by Dr. Tahir-ul-Qadri or “The Blessed Birth” by Shaykh Gibril Haddad tread similar ground. However, Hammad Raza’s work is unique in its focus on classical scholarship combined with local cultural practices.

Where Haddad’s work is dense and Qadri’s sometimes veers into polemic, Raza maintains a balance. His style is scholarly but accessible—more suited to community readers and mosque-based discussion groups.

Eid Mawlid Al Nabi: A Celebration Rooted in Devotion

Why does celebrating Eid Mawlid al Nabi provoke such passionate debate?

Every year, millions decorate streets, light candles, and host processions under the banner of Eid Mawlid al Nabi, yet the theological divide remains. The book engages this practice by tracing its origins to Ottoman and earlier Islamic governance, asserting that celebration as gratitude is embedded in Islamic precedent.

Eid Mawlid al Nabi, Raza explains, is not a religious innovation but a cultural expression of love validated by scripture. Through case studies, including accounts from Egypt and Morocco, he supports this claim.

Happy Birthday Nabi: Language of Love or Theological Misstep?

Can we really say ‘Happy Birthday Nabi’? That question opens one chapter.

Raza confronts linguistic modernism by framing such greetings as contemporary metaphors for devotion. He explains that in non-Arabic speaking contexts, saying “Happy Birthday Nabi” functions as an emotional declaration rather than a theological doctrine.

In sociolinguistic terms, it's akin to saying "May Allah bless the Prophet's day of birth." The book asserts this is not only permissible but may even deepen love among younger generations.

Happy Maulid Day: Social Sentiment and Cultural Embrace

Happy Maulid Day has become a trending phrase across Muslim social media, but does this modern phrase compromise Islamic values?

Raza explores this intersection, noting how digital expressions of love for the Prophet are part of a growing Islamic vernacular. Far from being trivial, these statements help revitalize interest in the Seerah.

Statistics show that online mentions of "Happy Maulid Day" peak in Rabi’ al-Awwal, especially in Southeast Asia and East Africa—regions where Raza’s book has also seen the highest sales.

Maulid Al Nabi: Bridging Scripture and Festivity

Is Maulid al Nabi more culture than creed?

Raza navigates this tension by demonstrating how both cultural practices and scriptural bases can co-exist. He references scholars like Imam Nawawi and Imam Ibn Kathir who supported Mawlid in some form.

In doing so, he reframes Maulid al Nabi as a hybrid phenomenon—part theology, part sociology. The book contends that as long as the core act is love for the Prophet, the outward forms can be culturally variable.

Nabi Muhammad Birthday: Remembering the Man, the Message

Is commemorating the Nabi Muhammad birthday just about the man or also about the mission?

Raza reminds us that remembering the Prophet’s birthday should be a gateway to reviving his teachings, not merely a festive moment. Through Qur’anic injunctions such as "Obey the Messenger" (Surah An-Nisa 4:59), the book links celebration to transformation.

The emphasis is clear: celebrate, yes—but live the message too.

Final Ruling

So, where do we stand?

Proof of Celebrating Mawlid-un Nabi from Quran and Sahih Hadith Hammad Raza, we are left with a strong, scripturally backed rationale for celebrating the birth of the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH). The arguments presented are coherent, the citations ample, and the tone respectfully persuasive.

Whether we say “Happy Maulid Day”, organize events for Mawlid al Nabi, or simply reflect on the Nabi Muhammad birthday in quiet gratitude, the book assures us: this is not heresy. It’s heritage.

After reading this book, usually people also search as following: Is Mawlid haram, how is mawlid al-nabi celebrated, Mawlid in Quran, Hadith on Mawlid, Is Milad allowed in Islam Sunni, Is Milad allowed in Islam Hanafi, Hadith on Milad un Nabi in Urdu, Who started Mawlid.

Then some of them also have some following questions:

1. What is the proof for celebrating Mawlid?
2. What does the Quran say about celebrating the prophet's birthday?
3. What is the Mawlid regarding the celebration of the Prophet's birthday?
4. Is it haram to celebrate Eid Milad un Nabi?
5. Is Mawlid haram in the Quran?
6. What is the proof of the Sunnah?
7. Is Mawlid bidah?
8. Do Sufis celebrate Mawlid?

Do you also have questions? Or curious about where you can download the book, read the book online, or buy the book online? Or want to add something more to the review above and give responses? You can write a comment below.

We also open services to review your book, ads and endorsement for your products or services, and affiliate program with the best commission to promote our books. Click Here to see the list of books that we provide.