Book Review: Justice of The Companions Murtaza Askari

Justice of The Companions

Book Review: Justice of The Companions Murtaza Askari

Before Buying, Better to Read the Book Review: Justice of The Companions Murtaza Askari by Legaproblema.com - Have you ever wondered how the concept of justice was embodied by the Islamic companions, or sahaba? The book Justice of The Companions Murtaza Askari offers a profound exploration into the justice of these revered figures in Islamic history. This work delves into the character and moral integrity of the sahaba justice, examining their role as exemplars of fairness and righteousness during the formative period of Islam. The book navigates through theological and historical perspectives, highlighting how the companions were selected and recognized for their just nature, which underpinned the early Islamic community development.¹

Justice, as portrayed in this book, is not merely a legal concept but a comprehensive ethical framework that the companions upheld. Their justice was integral to their leadership, jurisprudence, and transmission of the Prophet Muhammad teachings. By analyzing various schools of thought, including the School of Caliphate, the book presents how the companions’ justice was unanimously affirmed by classical scholars and remains a cornerstone in Islamic jurisprudential traditions.¹

This review will guide you through the book details, structure, strengths, and its impact on contemporary Islamic studies, while also addressing critiques and comparisons with similar works.

Book Details

Author

Sayyid Murtadha Al-Askari

Original Language

Arabic

Translation

English

Publisher

Al-Islam.org

ISBN

-

Length

150 pages

Genre

Islamic Theology, History, Jurisprudence

Structure and Contents

What makes the book Justice of The Companions Murtaza Askari stand out in its treatment of sahaba justice? The book is meticulously structured to provide a comprehensive understanding, including:

• Preface: Introduction to the concept of justice among the companions and its theological significance.
• Two Schools of Thought: Analysis of the School of Caliphate and alternative perspectives on the companions' justice.
• Scriptural Evidence: Presentation of Quranic verses and hadiths supporting the justice and integrity of the companions.¹
• Historical Narratives: Accounts of the companions’ lives illustrating their just conduct.
• Scholarly Opinions: Insights from classical scholars like Ibn Hajar, Ibn Katheer, and Abu Hatim Al-Razi affirming the companions' righteousness.¹
• Critical Analysis: Discussion on controversies and differing views within Islamic sects regarding the companions.
• Conclusion: Summary emphasizing the companions as models of justice for the Muslim community.

Strong Points of the Book

Why does this book resonate with readers interested in sahaba justice? Here are some of its key strengths:

• Comprehensive Scholarship: The book draws on a wide array of classical Islamic sources and scholars, providing depth and authenticity.¹
• Balanced Presentation: It fairly presents differing views while maintaining a respectful tone, avoiding unnecessary controversy.
• Clarity and Accessibility: Despite its scholarly content, the book is accessible to both academic and general readers interested in Islamic history.
• Focus on Justice: It uniquely centers on the theme of justice, a critical yet sometimes overlooked aspect of the companions' legacy.
• Integration of Theology and History: The book effectively links theological doctrines with historical realities of the companions’ lives.

Impact and Legacy

What impact has the book Justice of The Companions Murtaza Askari had on the understanding of Islamic companions and sahaba justice? This work has:

• Reinforced the traditional Sunni view affirming the justice and righteousness of all companions, helping to unify perspectives within Muslim scholarship.¹
• Provided a resource for educators and students to explore the ethical foundations of early Islamic governance and jurisprudence.
• Influenced contemporary discussions on the role of the companions in Islamic law and theology, particularly in debates about hadith authenticity and moral authority.
• Encouraged inter-sectarian dialogue by acknowledging differing views while emphasizing shared respect for the companions.

Murtaza Askari

Criticism of the Book

Does the book face any criticism regarding its portrayal of Islamic companions and sahaba justice? Critics have noted:

• Limited Sectarian Perspectives: While thorough from a Sunni viewpoint, the book may not fully engage with Shia critiques concerning the companions' justice.
• Potential Idealization: Some argue the book idealizes the companions, possibly overlooking complex historical realities and human flaws.
• Scarcity of Contemporary Analysis: The book focuses heavily on classical sources, with less emphasis on modern scholarly methods or historical criticism.

Comparison with Other Similar Books

How does this book compare to other works on Islamic companions and sahaba justice? Consider the following aspects:

Aspect	Justice of The Companions (Askari)	Other Similar Books
Focus	Centered on justice and moral integrity of companions	Often broader, covering biography or political history
Perspective	Primarily Sunni, classical scholarship	Varies; some include Shia perspectives or modern critiques
Depth	In-depth theological and jurisprudential analysis	Varies; some more narrative or historical
Accessibility	Accessible to both scholars and lay readers	Ranges from academic to popular

Islamic Companions: Who Were the Sahaba?

What defines the Islamic companions or sahaba, and why is their justice so pivotal? The companions were the Prophet Muhammad closest followers who witnessed his life and teachings firsthand. Their justice was not only a personal virtue but a societal necessity, as they laid the foundations of the Muslim community legal and ethical systems. Their role extended beyond companionship to active participation in battles, governance, and transmission of the Prophet traditions, making their justice a cornerstone of Islamic identity.²

Understanding their justice helps us appreciate how Islamic jurisprudence and moral codes evolved. The companions’ integrity ensured the reliability of hadith transmission and the legitimacy of early Islamic rulings, which continue to influence millions today.³

Sahaba Justice: Foundations of Islamic Ethics

Why is sahaba justice a subject of enduring interest? Justice among the companions was seen as divinely endorsed, protecting the community from error and discord. The book under review emphasizes that the companions were “just ones of the ummah,” safeguarded from mistakes in matters of faith and practice. This concept is vital because it underpins the acceptance of their narrations and decisions as authoritative.¹

Their justice also shaped the emergence of Islamic jurisprudential schools, as their interpretations and ijtihad (independent reasoning) influenced foundational legal thought. The companions’ justice is thus inseparable from the development of Islamic law and ethics, making this book a valuable contribution to understanding that legacy.

Final Ruling

In sum, the book Justice of The Companions Murtaza Askari offers a detailed, well-researched, and respectful examination of the justice of the Islamic companions. It serves as an essential resource for anyone interested in sahaba justice, Islamic history, and jurisprudence. While it predominantly reflects Sunni scholarship, its careful presentation and scholarly rigor make it a significant contribution to Islamic studies. This book invites readers to appreciate the companions not only as historical figures but as enduring exemplars of justice whose legacy continues to shape the Muslim world.

Do you also have questions? Or curious about where you can download the book, read the book online, or buy the book online? Or want to add something more to the review above and give responses? You can write a comment below.