Book Review: Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah

Book Review: Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah

Before Buying, Better to Read the Book Review: Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah by Legaproblema.com - What exactly constitutes islam crime and how does it differ from secular criminal systems? When we delve into the book Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah, we find a comprehensive exploration of Islamic criminal law that elucidates these questions with clarity. This full set by Abdul Qadir Oudah offers a detailed comparative study of Muslim criminal law, highlighting the principles of islamic criminal procedure and the nuances of sharia criminal law.

The work systematically addresses the classifications of crimes under Islamic law-Hudud, Qisas, and Ta'zir-and explains the rationale behind prescribed punishments, evidentiary standards, and judicial discretion. It also contrasts Islamic penal law with secular criminal codes, providing readers with a robust understanding of how Islamic jurisprudence approaches criminal justice within the Muslim world.

By unpacking the wisdom and logic behind rulings, Oudah set serves as an indispensable resource for scholars, legal practitioners, and anyone interested in the intersection of religion and law in Muslim societies.

Book Details

Author

Abdul Qadir Oudah

Original Language

Arabic

Translation

English

Publisher

Adam Publishers, India

ISBN

8174354328

Length

201 pages

Genre

Islamic Legal Studies, Comparative Criminal Law

Structure and Contents

How is the book Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah organized to tackle the complexities of muslim criminal law? The set is structured to provide a methodical and exhaustive examination of Islamic criminal jurisprudence, including:

• Introduction to Islamic criminal law and its foundational sources (Quran, Sunnah, consensus, analogy)
• Detailed discussion of crime categories: Hudud (fixed punishments), Qisas (retaliation and blood money), and Ta'zir (discretionary punishments)
• Comparative analysis with secular criminal law systems, highlighting similarities and differences
• Exploration of procedural aspects, evidentiary requirements, and judicial discretion in Islamic courts
• Examination of contemporary issues such as the age of criminal responsibility and the principle of nulla poena sine lege
• Practical applications and case studies illustrating the implementation of Islamic penal law in various Muslim countries

This comprehensive layout ensures readers gain both theoretical knowledge and practical insights into islamic penal law.

Strong Points of the Book

What makes this work stand out in the field of sharia criminal law studies? The book Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah excels in several areas:

• Comprehensive Scope: Covers all major and minor problems in Islamic criminal law, leaving no doctrine untouched²
• Comparative Perspective: Offers a balanced comparison with secular law, useful for cross-cultural legal understanding²
• Clarity and Depth: Explains complex legal concepts with accessible language and detailed reasoning
• Authoritative Scholarship: Authored by a respected Islamic legal scholar with deep roots in Islamic jurisprudence and activism²
• Practical Relevance: Discusses logic and wisdom behind rulings, aiding application in contemporary legal systems

Impact and Legacy

Why does the book Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah continue to be relevant in discussions of islam crime and legal reform? Its impact is multi-faceted:

• It has become a key reference for scholars and students of Islamic law worldwide, bridging traditional jurisprudence with modern legal challenges.
• The book influenced debates on integrating Islamic penal codes within national legal frameworks, especially in countries reconsidering the role of sharia criminal law.
• It supports legal practitioners and policymakers in understanding the philosophical and procedural bases of Muslim criminal law, facilitating informed decisions.
• Its legacy includes fostering greater awareness and respect for Islamic legal traditions in comparative law studies.

Abdul Quadir Oudah

Criticism of the Book

Does the book Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah face any critiques regarding its treatment of islamic criminal procedure? Some points raised include:

• Accessibility: The depth and volume of material may overwhelm casual readers or those new to Islamic law.
• Perspective Bias: As the author was a proponent of full implementation of Islamic law, some critics argue the work may underrepresent reformist or secular viewpoints.
• Availability: The full set is currently out of stock in some markets, limiting access to interested readers².
• Modern Application: Some scholars debate the practicality of applying classical rulings in contemporary pluralistic societies.

Comparison with Other Similar Books

How does this work compare to other texts on muslim criminal law and islamic penal law? Below is a brief comparison:

Aspect	Abdul Qadir Oudah Set	Other Islamic Criminal Law Texts	Secular Criminal Law Studies
Scope	Comprehensive, multi-volume, covers all major doctrines	Often focused on specific schools or topics	Focus on statutory and case law, secular principles
Comparative Analysis	Explicit comparison with secular law	Limited or no comparative focus	Rarely includes Islamic law
Author Perspective	Pro-Sharia implementation	Varies from reformist to traditionalist	Neutral or secular viewpoint
Usefulness for Practitioners	High, especially in Muslim jurisdictions	Variable depending on focus	High in secular contexts

Islam Crime: Understanding the Foundations

Ever wondered how islam crime is defined and treated differently from other legal systems? The book Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah clarifies that crimes under Islamic law are not merely offenses against society but often considered offenses against divine boundaries (Hudud). This theological underpinning shapes the nature of punishments and procedures, distinguishing Islamic criminal law from secular codes⁶.

Islamic criminal law classifies crimes into fixed categories with specific penalties, emphasizing moral and social order as defined by Sharia. Oudah work meticulously explains these categories and the rationale behind them, providing a foundational understanding of islam crime.

Islamic Criminal Procedure: The Path to Justice

What makes islamic criminal procedure distinct in the administration of justice? The procedural framework in Islamic law, as detailed in Oudah set, balances strict evidentiary standards with judicial discretion. Questions such as “Who decides guilt?” and “How is evidence evaluated?” are answered through the lens of Sharia jurisprudence.

The book elaborates on the role of the Qadi (judge), the importance of witness testimony, and the application of procedural norms that safeguard fairness while upholding divine law. This procedural insight is crucial for understanding how Muslim criminal law operates in practice⁵⁶.

Islamic Penal Law: Punishments and Principles

What are the key features of islamic penal law that differentiate it from other legal systems? Oudah comprehensive volumes delve into the classifications of punishments-Hudud, Qisas, and Ta'zir-and the conditions under which they apply.

He explains the fixed nature of Hudud punishments, the retaliatory justice of Qisas, and the discretionary Ta'zir penalties administered by rulers or judges. The book also discusses the underlying principles such as deterrence, retribution, and rehabilitation within Islamic penal philosophy²⁵.

Muslim Criminal Law: Tradition Meets Modernity

How does muslim criminal law reconcile centuries-old traditions with contemporary legal challenges? Oudah work addresses this by situating Islamic criminal law within both historical contexts and modern legal debates.

The set discusses how Islamic jurisprudence adapts to new circumstances while maintaining fidelity to Sharia, highlighting ongoing discussions about reform, human rights, and the role of Islamic law in pluralistic societies²⁶.

Sharia Criminal Law: Implementation and Challenges

Is sharia criminal law uniformly applied across Muslim countries? Oudah volumes reveal the diversity in implementation, influenced by local customs, legal traditions, and political factors.

The book examines case studies and legal reforms that illustrate the challenges and successes in applying Sharia criminal law today, emphasizing the dynamic nature of Islamic legal systems and their interaction with international human rights norms²⁶.

Final Ruling

In sum, the book Criminal Law Of Islam Full Set Abdul Quadir Oudah stands as an authoritative and indispensable resource for understanding the complexities of Islamic criminal law. It adeptly covers islam crime, islamic criminal procedure, islamic penal law, muslim criminal law, and sharia criminal law with scholarly rigor and accessible clarity.

For those seeking a deep, comparative, and practical insight into Islamic criminal justice, Oudah full set remains unmatched in scope and depth, offering essential knowledge for academics, legal professionals, and policymakers alike.

Citation

1. Goodreads. "Criminal Law of Islam by Abdul Qadir Oudah." Retrieved 2025.
2. Kitaabun. "Criminal Law of Islam By AQ 'Oudah [Comparative Study W/ Secular]." Adam Publishers, ISBN 8174354328.
3. Noor-Book. "Criminal Law Of Islam Vol 1 (English) By Abdul Qadir Oudah." 2021.
4. Noor-Book. "Criminal Law Of Islam Vol 2 (English) By Abdul Qadir Oudah." 2021.
5. Oxford Academic. "12 Islamic Criminal Law." The Oxford Handbook of Criminal Law, 2014.
6. Wikipedia. "Islamic criminal jurisprudence." 2025.