Book Review: Al Wala Wal Bara Full Set Muhammad Ibn Saeed Ibn Salim Al Qahtani
.png "Al Wala Wal Bara Full Set Muhammad Ibn Saeed Ibn Salim Al Qahtani") |
| Al Wala Wal Bara Full Set |
Book Review: Al Wala Wal Bara Full Set Muhammad Ibn Saeed Ibn Salim Al Qahtani
Before Buying, Better to Read the Book Review: Al Wala Wal Bara Full Set Muhammad Ibn Saeed Ibn Salim Al Qahtani by Legaproblema.com - What does loyalty mean when it is framed through the prism of faith? How does one navigate the concept of being loyal or disavowing in a religious context? These questions are central to the Book Al Wala Wal Bara Full Set Muhammad Ibn Saeed Ibn Salim Al Qahtani, a profound exploration of the Islamic doctrine of loyalty (al-wala) and disavowal (al-bara). This full set by Shaykh Muhammad ibn Saeed ibn Salim al-Qahtani offers a detailed, scholarly exposition on these pivotal concepts within the Salaf Aqeedah tradition.1
The work meticulously outlines the theological foundations and practical implications of loving what Allah loves and disavowing what He hates, a duality that shapes Muslim identity and community boundaries. The author, a respected scholar from Saudi Arabia, draws extensively from Qur’anic verses, authentic Hadiths, and the sayings of early Muslim scholars to present a comprehensive framework.2
This set is not just a theological treatise but a guide to understanding the dynamics of allegiance and separation in Islam, emphasizing the importance of loyalty to the Muslim community and disavowal of disbelief and practices contrary to Islamic teachings. It is a critical resource for those seeking to grasp the nuances of this doctrine in contemporary Islamic thought.3
Book Details
Author
Shaykh Muhammad ibn Saeed ibn Salim al-Qahtani
Original Language
Translation
English
Publisher
Al-Firdous Publications (English edition)
ISBN
-.
Length
The full set comprises three volumes, each containing detailed chapters and extensive references, totaling several hundred pages.6
Genre
Islamic Theology, Aqeedah, Religious Studies
Structure and Contents
How is such a complex doctrine structured for readers? The Book Review: al wala wal bara full set muhammad ibn saeed ibn salim al qahtani is organized to progressively build understanding, from foundational concepts to practical applications.7
- Introduction and Definition: Clarifies the meaning of al-wala (loyalty) and al-bara (disavowal) within Islamic theology.
- The Declaration of Faith: Explores how loyalty and disavowal underpin the Muslim declaration of faith.
- Love and Hate in Faith: Examines the emotional and spiritual dimensions of loyalty and disavowal.
- Effects on the Heart: Discusses the impact of these concepts on a believer inner life and community relations.
- What Negates Faith: Identifies actions and beliefs that contradict true loyalty and disavowal.
- Historical Examples: Uses examples from the Qur’an and early Islamic history to illustrate the doctrine in practice.
- Practical Rulings: Addresses contemporary issues such as social relations, marriage, and political allegiance.
This structure ensures readers not only understand the theory but also see its application, supported by rigorous scholarship and authentic sources.8
Strong Points of the Book
What makes this full set a standout in Islamic theological literature? The Book Review: al wala wal bara full set muhammad ibn saeed ibn salim al qahtani excels in several areas:9
- Authoritative Scholarship: The author deep expertise and meticulous referencing of Qur’an, Hadith, and classical scholars lend the work high credibility.
- Comprehensive Coverage: The doctrine of loyalty and disavowal is explored in breadth and depth, covering theological, emotional, and social dimensions.
- Clarity and Accessibility: Despite its scholarly nature, the text is structured to be accessible to serious students of Islamic theology.
- Contextual Relevance: The book addresses contemporary challenges facing Muslims, making the doctrine relevant today.
- Balanced Approach: While firm on principles, it also discusses the nuances of application, such as respect for Muslim minorities and relatives.
Impact and Legacy
How has the Book Review: al wala wal bara full set muhammad ibn saeed ibn salim al qahtani influenced Islamic thought? Since its publication, it has become a key reference for understanding the Salafi perspective on loyalty and disavowal.10
The work has shaped scholarly discourse and religious education, especially in Saudi Arabia and Salafi circles worldwide. It has also informed debates on Muslim identity, interfaith relations, and the boundaries of allegiance in Islam.1
Its legacy is visible in how contemporary Islamic scholars and students approach the concepts of loyalty and disavowal, emphasizing adherence to Qur’anic principles while navigating modern social realities.2
.jpg "Al Wala Wal Bara Full Set Muhammad Ibn Saeed Ibn Salim Al Qahtani") |
| Muhammad Ibn Saeed Ibn Salim Al Qahtani |
Criticism of the Book
Is the doctrine of loyalty and disavowal without controversy? The Book Review: al wala wal bara full set muhammad ibn saeed ibn salim al qahtani has faced criticism, particularly regarding its social and political implications.3
Critics argue that a strict interpretation of al-wala wal-bara can foster exclusivism and social division, potentially leading to intolerance or isolation from non-Muslim communities. Some scholars outside the Salafi tradition caution that the doctrine, if applied rigidly, may hinder integration and peaceful coexistence in pluralistic societies.4
However, defenders emphasize the theological basis and argue that the book provides necessary boundaries for preserving Islamic identity and faithfulness.5
Comparison with Other Similar Books
How does this full set compare with other Islamic works on loyalty and disavowal? Unlike many texts that treat the topic briefly, Shaykh al-Qahtani work stands out for its exhaustive detail and scholarly rigor.6
| Aspect | Al-Qahtani Full Set | Other Similar Works |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Comprehensive, 3 volumes covering theology, history, and application | Often limited to essays or shorter treatises |
| Scholarly Rigor | Extensive referencing of Qur’an, Hadith, and classical scholars | Varies; some lack detailed citations |
| Accessibility | Structured for serious students and scholars | Some more accessible but less detailed |
| Focus | Salafi Aqeedah perspective | Broader Islamic perspectives, including Sunni and Shia views |
Loyalty: The Heart of Al-Wala Wal-Bara
What does it mean to be truly loyal in the context of al-wala wal-bara? Loyalty here transcends mere allegiance; it is a spiritual and communal bond rooted in love for what Allah loves-primarily the Muslim community, faith, and Shariah.7
The book elucidates how this loyalty is not blind but informed by scripture and tradition, guiding Muslims to support and defend their faith and fellow believers. It is a call to embody faith through steadfast allegiance, fostering unity and resilience within the Ummah.8
Loyal: Being Faithfully Committed
How does one live as a loyal Muslim according to al-Qahtani teachings? Loyalty involves active commitment-upholding Islamic values, supporting the community, and distancing oneself from actions or beliefs that contradict Islam.9
The full set details that loyalty is both an internal conviction and an external practice, influencing social interactions, political stances, and personal conduct. It is a dynamic state of being that requires constant vigilance and sincerity.10
Disavowal: The Other Side of Faith
Is disavowal simply about hatred? The concept of disavowal (al-bara) in the book is more nuanced-it is a necessary rejection of disbelief and practices opposed to Islam, motivated not by personal animosity but by obedience to divine command.1
Disavowal serves as a protective mechanism for the faith, ensuring that Muslims maintain purity of belief and practice. The author emphasizes that this disavowal is balanced with wisdom and justice, avoiding excess and fostering a clear Islamic identity.2
Final Ruling
In sum, the book Al Wala Wal Bara Full Set Muhammad Ibn Saeed Ibn Salim Al Qahtani presents a definitive guide on the doctrine of loyalty and disavowal. It calls us to a profound understanding of allegiance in Islam-rooted in love for the faith and community, and disavowal of what contradicts it.3
While the doctrine may challenge modern notions of pluralism, the book insists on its theological necessity and offers a framework for faithful Muslims to navigate their identity with clarity and conviction.4
For those seeking a detailed, scholarly, and authoritative resource on al-wala wal-bara, this full set remains indispensable.5
Then some of them also have some following questions:
- What is the meaning of al wala wal bara?
- What is al wala wal bara according to the aqeedah of the salaf?
- Who wrote Al Wala Wal Bara?
- What is the meaning of Al-Bara?
- What is the Baraa in the Quran?
- Why is it called Allahu Akbar?
- What are the 5 pillars of Salafi?
- What is Al Wala Wal Bara in Islamqa?
- Was the Prophet a salaf?
Citation
- https://adviceforparadise.com/profiles/12/
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Wala'_wal-Bara'
- https://fitrahtawheed.com/al-wala-wal-bara
- https://islamqa.info/en/answers/337640/the-concept-of-loyalty-and-disavowal-al-wala-wal-bara-and-its-importance
- https://kalamullah.com/Books/alWalaawalBaraa1.pdf
- https://missionislam.com/knowledge/books/Al%20Wala%20wal%20Bara%20Part%202.pdf
- https://missionislam.com/knowledge/books/Al%20Wala%20Wal%20Bara%20Part%203.pdf
- https://onlineislamicbook.com/products/al-wala-wal-bara-part-1-2-3-by-muhammad-saeed-al-qahtaani
- https://www.allahsword.com/ebooks/Islamic%20Belief/wala%20wal%20bara%20-%202.pdf
- https://www.eurasiareview.com/20112015-forging-muslim-and-non-muslim-relationship-contesting-doctrine-of-al-wala-wal-bara-analysis/
0Comments