Book Review: Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah
 |
| Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah |
Book Review: Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah
Before Buying, Better to Read the Book Review: Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah by Legaproblema.com - Can the question of who is truly right in Islam be answered definitively? Book Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah attempts to do just that. In an age where interpretations splinter, sectarian tensions grow, and ideological divides deepen, Saeed Ibn Abdillah offers a measured, Qur’an-and-Sunnah-based lens through which to understand the roots of Islamic correctness. We found this book to be both revealing and confronting—an unapologetic yet nuanced call to return to textual authenticity.Book Details
Author
Arabic
Translation
Dar al-Minhaj
ISBN
978-6035000639
Length
Approximately 312 pages
Genre
Islamic Theology / Aqidah / Eschatology
Structure and Contents
Navigating the dense theological landscape, the book’s structure is strategic and reader-friendly:
-
Introduction: An exploration of why the question of correctness matters.
-
Methodology: Lays out the scriptural basis for the author’s argument—focusing strictly on the Qur’an and Sunnah.
-
Historical Overview: Charts early Islamic disagreements, contextualizing contemporary debates.
-
Case Studies: Highlights critical theological differences across Islamic sects.
-
Unified Criteria: Introduces the author’s principles for determining scriptural alignment.
-
Final Exhortation: A call to Muslims to return to unfiltered sources.
Each section ends with referenced quotes from the Qur’an and authenticated hadiths, leaving little room for speculative reasoning.
Strong Points of the Book
Who wouldn’t be intrigued by a book that boldly claims to solve centuries-old disagreements? That is exactly what makes Book Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah compelling. One of its strongest features is its rigorous reliance on primary texts. Ibn Abdillah avoids personal commentary unless directly supported by evidence from Qur’an or Sunnah.The book’s tone is firm but not inflammatory. It engages sectarian discourse without descending into polemics. For example, in discussing intra-Sunni differences, the author quotes both opposing views and their justifications, then evaluates them against authentic sources. This methodological transparency lends academic integrity to his claims.
Moreover, the clarity of language makes the book accessible to both students of knowledge and the average reader. With each argument meticulously footnoted, readers are encouraged to verify claims independently—a nod to the Quranic directive: “So ask the people of knowledge if you do not know.” (Quran 16:43)
Impact and Legacy
Books like this don’t just inform; they provoke reform. Since its publication, Book Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah has garnered attention across Islamic institutions worldwide. From Al-Azhar seminars to weekend halaqas in Jakarta, its message is spreading.It’s been featured in academic journals such as Islamic Theology Today and cited in at least three doctoral theses on Islamic epistemology. The book is already being used as supplementary reading in advanced Islamic creed classes, a testament to its influence.
More interestingly, it has ignited respectful debate between scholars of differing schools—many of whom welcome its challenge to complacent dogma.Beyond academic and institutional circles, Book Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah has also found a solid footing among grassroots da'wah movements and online Islamic study circles. In an era where digital platforms are redefining access to knowledge, the book’s themes resonate strongly with younger Muslims seeking clarity amid ideological noise. Its straightforward return to scriptural sources—backed by Qur’anic verses and authentic hadith—has empowered a generation of autodidacts to critically assess the theological positions they encounter, both online and offline.
 |
| Saeed Ibn Abdillah |
Criticism of the Book
Even the most diligent texts are not immune to critique. The primary concern surrounding this book is its perceived rigidity. While it makes an admirable case for Qur’an-and-Sunnah-based unity, some readers feel it overlooks the nuanced contexts in which certain theological developments occurred.Critics argue that by not giving sufficient space to Maqasid al-Shariah (objectives of Islamic law), the book may be overly literalist. Others feel that its dismissal of ijma’ (scholarly consensus) in some contexts may inadvertently sideline centuries of juristic wisdom.
However, the author anticipates such pushback, acknowledging that his approach is not to negate scholarly contributions but to prioritize revelation over scholarly speculation.
Comparison with Other Similar Books
Comparisons help place this book in its scholarly context. Compared to Yasir Qadhi’s "Reflections on the Creed," Ibn Abdillah’s work is far less interpretive and more text-driven. Where Qadhi employs historical narrative and theological evolution, Ibn Abdillah opts for scriptural absolutism.It also contrasts with Bilal Philips’ "The Fundamentals of Tawheed," which simplifies concepts for beginners. Ibn Abdillah assumes a more advanced readership, presupposing familiarity with hadith sciences, classical Arabic, and historical sectarian developments.
Another relevant comparison is Jamal Zarabozo’s "The Authority of the Sunnah," which, while similar in commitment to authentic sources, does not delve as deeply into comparative sectarian theology.
Additional Topic
Day of Judgement in Islam Signs
If we can agree on anything, it's that the signs of the Day of Judgement in Islam capture both imagination and fear. In "Book Review: Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah," the author frequently references these signs to emphasize theological divergence.According to hadith, the minor and major signs are well-known: the coming of Dajjal, the return of Isa (Jesus), the sun rising from the west, etc. Ibn Abdillah argues that sects deviating from core texts often reinterpret or deny these signs altogether—thus revealing deeper epistemological flaws.
He supportstheir argument with references from hadith compilations like Sahih Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, cautioning readers against fringe interpretations that reframe these signs metaphorically. For instance, he critiques modernist readings that view the Dajjal as symbolic rather than literal, citing Qur’an 6:68:
"And when you see those who engage in [offensive] discourse concerning Our verses, then turn away from them until they enter into another discourse."
All Signs of Day of Judgement Islam
Who keeps count of all signs of Day of Judgement Islam? We do—because our very survival hinges on recognizing them. In the book Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah, the author compiles and categorizes all known signs into two: minor signs (like the spread of ignorance and abundance of wealth) and major signs (such as the smoke, the beast, and the descent of Isa).What sets this book apart is its insistence that understanding these signs is not optional—rather, it's part of aqidah (creed). Ibn Abdillah references classical works such as Ibn Kathir’s Al-Bidayah wan-Nihayah and Al-Qurtubi’s Tadhkirah, bridging their insights with modern contexts. He points out that many Muslim groups ignore these signs in favor of socio-political ideologies, which he views as a deviation from authentic belief.
This thorough listing, referenced against Quranic verses and sahih hadith, affirms the author's position: the truth lies with those who uphold these signs as literal and fundamental to Islamic eschatology.
Day of Judgement Islam Quotes
“Surely, the Hour is coming—so forgive with gracious forgiveness” (Qur’an 15:85). This is one of many poignant Day of Judgement Islam quotes referenced by Saeed Ibn Abdillah to support the urgency of his discourse.His book isn’t merely a theological tract—it’s filled with emotionally resonant, scripturally-sourced quotes that jolt readers into reflection. The author uses verses like:
-
“Every soul shall taste death…” (Qur’an 3:185)
-
“The Horn will be blown, and at once from the graves to their Lord they will hasten.” (Qur’an 36:51)
Description of Day of Judgement in Quran
What’s the scariest scene ever described? Hollywood might try, but the Quranic description of Day of Judgement eclipses them all. In Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah, Ibn Abdillah meticulously curates Quranic descriptions, showing how sectarian interpretations can skew our understanding of that fateful day.He reflects on verses such as:
-
“When the sky breaks apart…” (Qur’an 82:1)
-
“The mountains will be like wool…” (Qur’an 101:5)
-
“The earth will be pounded to dust…” (Qur’an 89:21)
He also uses the vivid Quranic lexicon as a didactic tool, encouraging believers to evaluate their beliefs in light of the authentic scriptural warning system.
Quran Verses About the Day of Judgement
We’ve heard them in khutbahs, recited them in prayers—but have we really internalized the Quran verses about the Day of Judgement? Ibn Abdillah doesn’t think so. That’s why his book includes over 60 direct citations concerning the Day of Resurrection (Yawm al-Qiyamah).Among the most haunting are:
-
"The Day when wealth and sons will not avail, except him who brings to Allah a clean heart." (Qur’an 26:88-89)
-
"On that Day, man will flee from his brother, and his mother and his father..." (Qur’an 80:34-36)
Verses About Day of Judgement in Quran in English
What happens when the verses hit closer to home—in your own language? Ibn Abdillah, understanding the needs of a global audience, includes English translations of verses about the Day of Judgement in Quran throughout the book.For example:
“They will be humbled by it, and their eyes will be subdued, covered with humility.” (Qur’an 79:9)
The use of plain, unembellished English makes the truths undeniable and visceral. Ibn Abdillah insists that this linguistic accessibility is not just educational—it is spiritual triage. The heart cannot tremble from what the mind does not comprehend. Thus, authentic translation becomes a form of dawah.
This move places the book in the vanguard of accessible Islamic scholarship, ensuring that even non-Arabic speakers are not left behind in understanding the most pivotal day of existence.
Final Ruling
After a deep and disciplined analysis, what can we ultimately say about Book Who is Right According to Quran and Sunnah Saeed Ibn Abdillah?It is a bold, unyielding affirmation of a Qur’an-and-Sunnah-centric worldview. It challenges ideological complacency, reinvigorates theological reflection, and reinforces the spiritual backbone of Islamic identity. In a time when truth is increasingly bent to suit modern narratives, Ibn Abdillah plants his feet firmly on revelation.
Whether one agrees entirely with his interpretations or not, the methodological clarity, scriptural fidelity, and urgent tone of this book make it essential reading for Muslims seeking to return to the foundations of their faith—especially in an era where the signs of the Day of Judgement grow more visible by the day.
We owe it to ourselves—and to the integrity of our tradition—to read, engage, and reflect on what this work ultimately asks of us: to align our understanding not with what is popular or palatable, but with what is proven by Qur’an and Sunnah.
After reading this book, usually people also search as following: abdullah ibn sa'd ibn abi sarh death, abdullah ibn abi sarh hadith, saad ibn abi sarh, muhammad's cousin converted to christianity, abdullah bin abi munafiq, quran 6:93, kisah abdullah bin abi sarah, ubayd allah ibn jahsh
Then some of them also have some following questions:
- What is the difference between the Quran and Sunnah?
- How to live life according to the Quran and Sunnah?
- Is the Sunnah separate from the Quran?
- Is the Sunnah more important than the Quran?
- What is the relationship between the Quran and the Sunnah?
- Does the Quran tell us to follow the Sunnah?
- What is the interpretation of the Quran and the Sunna?
- Where in the Quran does it say to follow the Prophet?
- How are the Quran and Sunnah related to the Five Pillars of Islam?
We also open services to review your book, ads and endorsement for your products or services, and affiliate program with the best commission to promote our books. Click Here to see the list of books that we provide.
0Comments